Avoiding Babylon

Insanity Defense On Trial (LOCALS Only Show)

Subscriber Episode Avoiding Babylon Crew

This episode is only available to subscribers.

Avoiding Babylon +

Access to the FULL show on audio!

Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link!

A mother kills her children, the internet rushes to explain it away, and a courtroom has to decide what “insanity” actually means. We work through the Lindsay Clancy trial with a focus on the part most people miss: Massachusetts still puts key pressure on the prosecution when insanity is claimed, and that burden of proof shapes how every detail lands with a jury. If you’ve felt confused by headlines, hot takes, and viral clips, we slow it down and ask what the law is really doing and what justice demands for the victims.

From there we get into the testimony that changed our read of the case, including the term “altruistic filicide,” the argument about planning versus psychosis, and the competing stories around psychiatric meds, doctor shopping, and the credibility of a suicide attempt. We also wrestle with the uncomfortable religious layer that shows up in the record: language about “going to God,” the courtroom blowup over mentioning mortal sin, and the bigger Catholic catechesis problem of people not knowing what the Church teaches about suicide, judgment, and sin.

Then the conversation broadens into culture. We respond to commentary that treats a public murder trial as a gratuitous spectacle, and we argue about whether privacy can outweigh justice. We also share clips and debates that expose the same pattern in the Church: Roy Schoeman’s critique of soft ecumenism and dual covenant theory, and a blunt back-and-forth on marriage, obedience, and what holiness actually demands when feelings change.

Finally, we hit the strange turn where Catholic mystical claims get repackaged as UFO or alien lore, and we lay out a simpler frame: saints, angels, demons, and the supernatural are not science fiction. If you want thoughtful, unfiltered commentary on true crime, Catholic theology, and the narratives shaping public life, subscribe, share this with a friend, and leave a review. What part of this story do you think the public is getting most wrong?


Get 10% off an amazing Black Monk Rosary by going to https://www.blackmonkrosaries.com/?ref=AVOIDINGBABYLON and using code AVOIDINGBABYLON at checkout!

Check out our sponsor, Nic Nac, at www.nicnac.com and use code "AB25%" for 25% off of your first order!

Please subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKsxnv80ByFV4OGvt_kImjQ?sub_confirmation=1

https://www.avoidingbabylon.com

Merchandise: https://avoiding-babylon-shop.fourthwall.com

Locals Community: https://avoidingbabylon.locals.com

Full Premium/Locals Shows on Audio Podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1987412/subscribe

RSS Feed for Podcast Apps: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1987412.rss

People on this episode